Are You Good at Giving Critiques?

One of Terry Stanley’s Photoshop critiques
One of Terry Stanley’s Photoshop critiques

On Art Critiques > Terry Stanley, an artist and art industry veteran who launched the Jack Richeson School of Art and marketed its art materials before retiring, offers what she has learned about the art of the critique in this special feature.

The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines critique as “a careful judgment in which you give your opinion about the good and bad parts of something (such as a piece of writing or a work of art).” What isn’t mentioned is the fact that there is an art to giving a critique as well as to receiving one.

Critique is a valuable tool which artists are exposed to as soon as they show their first piece of art to another person, and continues throughout their artistic life. If you think about it, you’ll realize that self-critique happens every time you make a correction in your artwork. Critique happens when you ask a friend what they think of a piece you’re working on. It happens when your work is hanging in a show and passers-by comment. More formal critiques happen in classes, workshops, competitions, and focused critique sessions offered to individuals or groups by a professional artist/instructor.

Terry Stanley helping a student in an SKB program
Terry Stanley helping a student in an SKB program

In the course of my career, I have been fortunate to have received the benefit of critiques from many excellent professionals. Some were quite harsh but veracious, some gentle and inane. As I developed as an artist and instructor, I worked on becoming someone who could deliver educated opinions that are accurate, pragmatic, and encouraging.

There are several aspects to consider in giving a formal critique. I believe an instructor should:

* Ask the artist if there any areas of concern in the artwork and what he or she thinks are the most successful parts

* Take the time to carefully look for all the hallmarks of a good piece of art. Composition, color use, perspective, proportion, technique, mastery of the applicable medium, etc. Take notes. The artist’s efforts are due the honor of careful consideration.

* Relay first what is right with the artwork. A dose of praise makes what follows more palatable.

* Start with the top three perceived flaws, and remember, kindness and honesty are not mutually exclusive. If the artist is receiving the information well, move on to other corrections that are needed.

* Offer suggestions on how to fix the items needing attention and/or where the artist might find those answers.

I have found digital media to be a very useful tool in giving critiques. If possible, I like to take a picture of the artwork being critiqued, open it in Photoshop, and mark up the image as the critique proceeds. Not only does this provide visual cues along with my narrative, but I can later e-mail the marked-up image to the artist. If I’m doing a phone or online critique, I usually also provide a written summary of my opinions.

Mehl Lawson offering outdoor critiques
Mehl Lawson offers an outdoor critique during a recent Salmagundi Club event in California

Creating art is a very personal endeavor, and receiving a critique can be intimidating! It’s important to remember that critique is a tool to assist you in your artistic growth, and it’s not a personal attack. If you have sought out the critique, chances are the person giving it is someone you respect and he or she is doing the job you’ve asked them to do. If they are successful in that job, you will come away from the critique with important information that will make you a better artist.


Pastel Live banner

Visit EricRhoads.com to find out all the amazing opportunities for artists through Streamline Publishing, including:
– Online art conferences such as Plein Air Live
– New video workshops for artists
– Incredible art retreats
– Educational and fun art conventions, and much more.

Learn More

> Subscribe to Plein Air Today, a free newsletter for artists
> Subscribe to PleinAir Magazine so you never miss an issue

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here